SQUAWK/NEWS
Account
Theme
Account
Menu
Live News NEWS ARTICLE H impact

View: Silicon Valley should ditch the ‘handover’ talking point

There’s no evidence we’re on the verge of the handover or anything remotely like it, so tech leaders would be wise to find a more optimistic talking point. The tech industry has enough of a public image problem with its warnings about AI leading to human extinction, and it risks further alienating people outside of Silicon Valley if it starts popularizing “the handover.” The handover is the period in which AI becomes so intelligent that it no longer makes sense for humans to make any decisions. Sam Altman brought the idea up on stage with me this week at Silicon Valley & The World, and he believes AI companies should do everything possible to avoid it. In a “positive” scenario, the handover turns humans into pets of AI overlords (Altman referenced Labradors): Humans have everything they need, from food to entertainment, and don’t need to work much. The dystopian idea is mostly a product of the Silicon Valley echo chamber, where those inside AI companies see advanced models in their raw forms, doing both scary things like breaking into the internet and amazing things like solving the world’s most difficult math theorems. There’s no evidence we’re on the verge of a handover or anythi

There’s no evidence we’re on the verge of the handover or anything remotely like it, so tech leaders would be wise to find a more optimistic talking point. The tech industry has enough of a public image problem with its warnings about AI leading to human extinction, and it risks further alienating people outside of Silicon Valley if it starts popularizing “the handover.” The handover is the period in which AI becomes so intelligent that it no longer makes sense for humans to make any decisions. Sam Altman brought the idea up on stage with me this week at Silicon Valley & The World, and he believes AI companies should do everything possible to avoid it.

In a “positive” scenario, the handover turns humans into pets of AI overlords (Altman referenced Labradors): Humans have everything they need, from food to entertainment, and don’t need to work much. The dystopian idea is mostly a product of the Silicon Valley echo chamber, where those inside AI companies see advanced models in their raw forms, doing both scary things like breaking into the internet and amazing things like solving the world’s most difficult math theorems. There’s no evidence we’re on the verge of a handover or anything remotely like it, so tech leaders would be wise to find a more optimistic talking point.

Related stories