UK motor insurance premiums rise 4.3% in August: Jefferies
Claims tracker shows claims inflation at 4.1% year on year in August Jefferies expects UK motor insurers to post 107% combined ratio in 2026 Average premiums up 41.7% since early 2019, against 61.1% rise in claims costs By Ryan Hewlett Sept 18 (The Insurer) — British motor insurance prices rose 4.3% year on year in August but deteriorated on a sequential basis, with under-pressure margins leaving the industry on track to post a loss-making 107% combined ratio in 2026, according to Jefferies analysts. Motor premiums rose for the ninth consecutive month, although the 4.3% year-on-year increase in August represented a slowdown from the 8.5% rise recorded in July. “British motor insurance price increases moderated in August, although it remains to be seen if this is a blip that reverses in the coming months,” Jefferies said. On a sequential basis, prices dropped 1.3% month on month, a reversal from the five consecutive monthly increases through July. “We continue to anchor our focus on the year-on-year trend, as this better reflects the lived realities of the consumer who operates on an annual renewal cycle,” Jefferies added. The investments bank’s claims tracker index showed claims d
Claims tracker shows claims inflation at 4.1% year on year in August Jefferies expects UK motor insurers to post 107% combined ratio in 2026 Average premiums up 41.7% since early 2019, against 61.1% rise in claims costs By Ryan Hewlett Sept 18 (The Insurer) — British motor insurance prices rose 4.3% year on year in August but deteriorated on a sequential basis, with under-pressure margins leaving the industry on track to post a loss-making 107% combined ratio in 2026, according to Jefferies analysts. Motor premiums rose for the ninth consecutive month, although the 4.3% year-on-year increase in August represented a slowdown from the 8.5% rise recorded in July.
“British motor insurance price increases moderated in August, although it remains to be seen if this is a blip that reverses in the coming months,” Jefferies said. On a sequential basis, prices dropped 1.3% month on month, a reversal from the five consecutive monthly increases through July. “We continue to anchor our focus on the year-on-year trend, as this better reflects the lived realities of the consumer who operates on an annual renewal cycle,” Jefferies added. The investments bank’s claims tracker index showed claims dropped 0.2% month on month, while the year-on-year figure shows inflation of 4.1%, roughly unchanged from 4.0% in July.
Jefferies said the relatively stable claims inflation figures were “somewhat surprising” given the disruption in the Middle East, adding that insurers continue to assume a higher inflation level of 5% to 7%, which it said “may prove to be appropriately prudent”. Cumulatively, Jefferies said the 41.7% change in average motor insurance premiums since the beginning of 2019 was far below the change in the cost of claims, which stood at 61.1% in August. “Premiums fell materially in 2024, with the cumulative change in premiums and claims (since pre-pandemic levels) implying that a margin deficit emerged in September 2024,” it said.
“That deficit widened materially and currently stands at -19.4%. We note that this deficit widened by +2.6%pts month-on-month.” Using the latest data, Jefferies said it expects the UK motor insurance industry’s 2026 combined ratio to remain loss-making at 107%. This compares with EY's estimate of 108%. “This is a -5%pts deterioration year-on-year, and slightly less cautious than EY's estimate of a -6%pts deterioration,” it said.
“Most recent cyclical lows were 112% in 2022-23 and 109% in 2016, which preceded the upturn in pricing. With 2026 being near these lows, we think an inflection looks close.”