Nike turnaround takes years as Wall Street questions margins

Nike Inc. ’s (NYSE: NKE ) stock-market round trip has begun to resemble a memecoin crash in slow motion.

It had a pandemic-era surge, a peak near $180, and then a grinding collapse below $40 as investors discovered the company’s growth story had been flattered by a strategy harder to unwind than to sell.

NKE stock, 2006-Present, Source: TradingView The analogy is far from perfect.

Nike still has one of the world’s best-known consumer brands, roughly $9 billion in cash and short-term investments, and a dividend yield of about 4%.

But the arc is familiar.

Expectations were pulled forward, margins were distorted, and the reversal could be taking years rather than months.

The Direct Model Trap Arguably, the ongoing problem stems from Nike’s direct-to-consumer pivot.

In 2017, the company launched a "Consumer Direct Offense," later accelerated in 2020 as "Consumer Direct Acceleration," to gain more control over customers and higher gross margins by pushing sales through its own channels.

Direct revenue rose 73% between 2020 and 2024, while wholesale revenue rose 20%.

The catch was operating leverage.

Nike pulled product from wholesale partners, added overhead, and gave rivals shelf space.

Operating margin fell from 13% to 8%, even with one-time tariff adjustments.

That left incoming Chief Executive Officer Elliott Hill, an intern who climbed to the top of the corporate ladder in 2024, with a repair job.

His approach was to clear inventory, rebuild wholesale relationships and move the company back toward sport-led categories through its new "Sport Offense" model.

Wall Street’s Patience Wears Thin However, Wall Street has become increasingly skeptical regarding Hill’s ability to " just do it ".

Earlier this month, JPMorgan analyst Matthew Boss downgraded Nike to Underweight, warning that "Win Now" decisions made through the end of calendar 2026 "will linger and impact NKE’s P&L in 2H27 and into FY28." JPMorgan cut its fiscal 2027 earnings estimate to $1.55 a share and fiscal 2028 to $1.72, framing fiscal 2028 as a stabilization year rather than a growth year.

The Chinese market became the company’s biggest drag.

Nike’s Greater China sales have fallen for eight straight quarters and are down about 30% since 2021, with annual revenue at an eight-year low.

The broader sportswear market in China has expanded, meaning Nike’s problem is less about demand than share loss.

Domestic rivals such as Anta and Li-Ning have benefited from "China Chic," or Guochao, as younger consumers increasingly favor local brands. "In a way, Nike has just become irrelevant," Yaling Jiang, founder of ApertureChina, told CNBC.

The competitive pressure is not limited to China.

In running, On and Hoka have gained share by emphasizing technical innovation.

On’s automated LightSpray process, which sprays a single-piece upper directly onto the sole, is one example. "What we’re doing now is on the bleeding edge of technology," On Co-CEO Caspar Coppetti told Forbes.

The Insider Bull Case While the stock price has been bleeding, the insiders have been buying.

Over the past 3 quarters, Hill has bought around $3 million in shares, while the longtime board member and Apple CEO Tim Cook purchased around $4 million.

Their stakes now total around 265,000 and 130,500, worth about $10.6 million and $5.2 million, respectively.

Yet, the firm’s turnaround is more than insider buying.

Nike’s story is a margin story, and management will have to prove it can restore profitability before the street starts trusting the firm again.

Photo: Shutterstock